THE STORY
In a shocking turn of events, Real Estate tycoon Richard Renthiker was discovered dead in his Park Avenue penthouse early this morning. The cause of death appears to be suffocation by pizza slice. That's right - pizza slice. Old man Renthiker was found with his mouth stuffed full of pepperoni with extra cheese.
Somebody must have had a real bone to pick with Renthiker, as this gruesome strangulation is not for the faint of heart, nor the lactose intolerant. Richard Renthiker was well respected in this town, but he also had a lot of enemies.
Somebody's lease on freedom is about to expire - could it have been Cal Zone, Moody Fooliani, Robin Banks, or even YOU??
Appropriate for ages 16+!
Mentions of hostages, alcohol, sexual references, adultery, cursing
This game takes 1-2 hours to play depending on group size.
**For personal use only. If you would like to host a public event using one of our games, please contact us at support@broadwaymurdermysteries.com to discuss licensing.
The mystery is built to be played by 4-20+ characters, ANY of whom could be the murderer and each have gripping motives for murder. **Additional guests can play as “detectives” who ask questions each round and guess the killer at the end!
| Cal Zone | he/him | Local Pizzeria owner |
| Richie Renthiker | he/him | Jr. Heir to the Renthiker fortune, Riki's twin |
| Riki Renthiker | she/her | Heiress to the Renthiker fortune, Rich Jr.'s twin |
| Gemma Renthiker-Galawinowitz | she/her | Wife of Rich Renthiker |
| Tina Tidier | she/her | Rich Renthiker's maid |
| Moody Fooliani | any | NYC Mayoral Candidate and close personal friend/attorney of Renthiker Corp. |
| Robin Banks | he/him | Rich Renthiker's Investment Banker |
| Phineas "Poppy" Seederman | he/him | Local Bagel shop owner |
| Dore Mann | he/him | Rich Renthiker's door man |
| Tori Takesatrip | she/her | A tourist from out of town visiting NYC |
| Shel Showmeister | he/him | A Broadway producer and business associate of Rich Renthiker |
| Lizzie "Legs" Long | she/her | An aspiring Broadway showgirl |
| Barry Tender | he/him | Local bar owner |
| Andy Chants | any | Local political organizer and activist |
| Bettina Barker | she/her | Rich Renthiker's dog walker |
| Bobbi Bikelane | any | A local food delivery person |
| Sammi Tation | he/him | A waste-management worker |
| Katie Keepsadate | she/her | Rich Renthiker's assistant |
| Kosciuszko | any | Rich Renthiker's dog |
| Murphy Bedman | he/him | Richard Renthiker's tenant |
